The Overlap Live Fan Debate 2.0: Gary Neville, Jamie Carragher & Paul Scholes | PL Returns Part 2

Part two, brought to you by Sky Bet, is out now ! I'm back with Jamie Carragher, Paul Scholes, Josh Denzel and some of the biggest fan channels in the UK.

We chat about Newcastle's takeover, a World Cup every two years and so much more.

I hope you all enjoy this video, make sure to subscribe and leave a like. We've got Carra's full interview coming out very soon as well !

0:00 - 16:53 Weighing up the Newcastle takeover, if Steve Bruce should stay & the impact on the Premier League
16:54 - 23:27 Will Rafa Benitez stay at Everton or could he be tempted by Newcastle?
23:28 - 35:05 Are Liverpool title contenders? And will Salah stay at the club?
35:06 - 44:01 Could we have a World Cup every 2 years?
44:02 - 50:43 Q&A!


  1. Sky Bet

    Sky Betأشهر قبل

    Will Salah leave Liverpool? 🤔

  2. Woobyung Chae

    Woobyung Chae11 أيام قبل

    No I don't think so

  3. Irwin M. Fletcher

    Irwin M. Fletcher12 أيام قبل

    Everyone’s talking about Madrid, Barca and PSG. Imagine Salah playing right wing next to Lewandowski at Bayern Munich. Sure, the Bundesliga is not as attractive as the PL and La Liga but they are a team that will be challenging for the CL title in the coming seasons and I think him and Lewan could be good together. Salah Gnarby + 50 mil? Gnabry might not be the answer here, maybe a lack of potential and not being on the same level as Salah would make a deal impossible. But I do think Salah would be great fit for them as he is not far from the type of player they had in Robben. In fairness, Bayern does not have a history of spending the kind of cash that is needed in bringing Mo to Munich. Who knows? Maybe him and a medically cleared Agüero could do some good under Xavi.

  4. Kane Evans

    Kane Evans29 أيام قبل

    What a stupid comment

  5. Brandulance io

    Brandulance ioأشهر قبل

    If he does he will leave with pride and a big thank you from any real Liverpool FC fan. He has already delivered time and time again. Without him there would be no League or Champions League trophies these past few seasons. He is a credit to the sport. Whatever his decision I think it will be respected by all. What a guy, what a player and what a goalscorer! YNWA

  6. The Maharani's Closet

    The Maharani's Closetأشهر قبل

    Whenever Liverpool play away!

  7. MS Hall

    MS Hall2 أيام قبل

    Barry probably wants Rafa out now 😄😄😄

  8. MS Hall

    MS Hall2 أيام قبل

    Love how blues still think Carras a blue. But not only is ne not. He hates them as well.

  9. J

    J3 أيام قبل

    Look at the cocky Arsenal fan keep smirking to himself every time the Newcastle fans talk facts. Why are all arsenal fans up their arse?

  10. boyoyongman

    boyoyongman5 أيام قبل

    I want to smoke whatever Scholes is having.

  11. boyoyongman

    boyoyongman5 أيام قبل

    Whenever I feel sad, I go back to this video and skip to the part where Paul Scholes criticizes Chelsea's defense... Meanwhile... ManU 0 LIV 5, ManU0 City 2, Leicester 4 ManU 2, Watford 4 ManU 1... Chelsea 3 Leicester 0, Chelsea 1 Malmo 0, Newcastle 0 Chelsea 3, Chelsea 7 Norwich 0

  12. Mixed Kebab Wrap

    Mixed Kebab Wrap7 أيام قبل

    Scholes musnt listen to the fans. Repeated exactly what they said twice in the first 2 discussions.

  13. Ben Grimes

    Ben Grimes7 أيام قبل

    Well said Gary the only time I will 👏👏👏

  14. Class5379

    Class53799 أيام قبل

    Tf is wrong with Russia?? Please tell me the human rights violations that are going on over there

  15. Someybear

    Someybear10 أيام قبل

    Who were the two good united centre backs that paul was referring to? im puzzled 🤨

  16. Deadfool

    Deadfool13 أيام قبل

    The toon fan called Eddie Howe

  17. Len Dowsey

    Len Dowsey13 أيام قبل

    Should get Gillette to sponsor the audience 😂😂😂

  18. Domantas

    Domantas13 أيام قبل

    I remember watching Basel in the champions league back in the day and noticing how good Salah was. It’s surreal seeing him being rated as one of the best in his position right now. Well played lad 👏

  19. Joseph Hall

    Joseph Hall14 أيام قبل

    The same people who complain about these human rights will be the same people sat in Qatar watching the world Cup..

  20. Ray K

    Ray K15 أيام قبل

    Love these!

  21. Whatcha73

    Whatcha7315 أيام قبل

    Hated Cara when playing for Liverpool being a Man U fan but seriously happy he didn't get sacked for spitting love him as a pundit and he makes Gary Neville.

  22. UZB7777

    UZB777715 أيام قبل

    Scholes a Chelsea hater tf talking out of his arse

  23. James Foley

    James Foley16 أيام قبل

    Great topic. Gary. What are your thoughts on your great mate Becks taking the blood soaked dollar to promote the net World Cup? We all want to earn as much money as we can. But when money is not an issue, surely his morals need to be called into question. I would love your thoughts?

  24. Swashworks

    Swashworks16 أيام قبل

    The thing about this independent regulator is just less people to corrupt.

  25. Ben Clarke

    Ben Clarke17 أيام قبل

    Video should’ve been called ‘let’s talk about all the rich teams’ Sky sports bullshit

  26. Fionn Hayes

    Fionn Hayes17 أيام قبل

    Neville saying he needs to go abroad and experience it! He has played Swiss league (:() and Italian league. Spanish league isn’t as it was. And French and German league is a 1 horse league. If he leaves it’s only money and greed…..

  27. Tommy Turner

    Tommy Turner18 أيام قبل

    The football clubs should be grateful to have International players playing for them. The players are Internationalists, not the owner of a football club.

  28. Dylan Kavanagh

    Dylan Kavanagh20 أيام قبل

    Top 6 rule the questios in this gary whats the point in inviting the lower league supporters if they cant express their opinion only bone to pick about a great overlap

  29. Ben Thausmann

    Ben Thausmann21 أيام قبل

    Can i ask, the Euro and World-cup every 2 years, if the players don't want it, what is keeping them from saying no thank you for a country call up ?

  30. Mark WJW WHUFC

    Mark WJW WHUFC22 أيام قبل

    newcastle worst training ground in the league?! u havent seen west hams portacabins!

  31. KRog yt

    KRog yt22 أيام قبل

    The chelsea take from scholes is such a weird one

  32. Jay M

    Jay M23 أيام قبل

    No one seems to be mentioning that it’s a Public Investment Fund. It’s not £300bn to spend - it’s a fund that needs to make a return for the benefit of the people of the Kingdom. It’s not an individual with a personal cheque book like Chelsea. I’m not saying they won’t spend loads I’m just saying it’s a completely different structure which no one seems to be commenting on?

  33. craycray

    craycray24 أيام قبل

    Scholes opinion on Chelsea's defence didn't age well

  34. SOUL BOY

    SOUL BOY24 أيام قبل

    It's a sad day for football

  35. Planet Of the ape man

    Planet Of the ape man24 أيام قبل

    Hey Muslims listen up. We’ve bought this crappy club in England as a play toy. And we will make it good. But now they say we have to treat women and none Muslims people good. Yep Muslims will all change now well done Gary👏🏻👏🏻

  36. Joshua Hague

    Joshua Hague25 أيام قبل

    I'd like to see someone else on from man u fans and arsenal fans ty is dumb and mckola acts like a baby

  37. The 11 meters  D.X. Channel.

    The 11 meters D.X. Channel.25 أيام قبل

    Paul Scholes ?? Chelsea running away with the title ...

  38. D S R

    D S R27 أيام قبل

    Newcastle could be competing for the title in a couple of years. That is just weird to even think about. They're not the only team with dubious owners tbf and Chelsea were rightly mentioned in that respect. You just know Abramovich has a few skeletons in his closet. You can't be ok with making arms deals with Saudi Arabia, but not be ok with them buying a football team.

  39. Jack Smith

    Jack Smith27 أيام قبل

    Bristol Rovers are in the top 10 richest clubs in the world...but they cant use that money and are shit lool Bristol is an untapped mine of Footballing talent, has 2 shit clubs, both have the money to progress, neither can actually really use their money as they would like, Bristol's in the top 5 biggest citys in the UK, it should have a Prem closed , end of story..over the likes of Brighton and others, its a crime there is no top flight team from Bristol, and also a crime that there probably now never will be. Bristol also has a huge amount of grass roots football, its one of the biggest grass roots area's in the country. Just think how much talent has already been squandered? 5th largest city in the UK pretty much ignored by the footballing world, with a Grass roots structure that is in the top 5 in terms of size and scope (meaning there are FUCK loads of players here, but there is little chance of Prem progression,, we also have some very high level grass roots teams, that get to Finals and stuff). Football world is joke, its the modern day Gladiator games, distraction whilst the big players move pieces about, maybe it should not be let them eat Cake, but let them see fake. this was a statement , not a discussion, or an attempt to start anything.

  40. Jack Smith

    Jack Smith27 أيام قبل

    15:21 You absolutely can change it now....but it would take a lot of effort and probably decades, but its s human structure, it can be changed

  41. Jack Smith

    Jack Smith27 أيام قبل

    08:30 Paul put the spade down,stop digging Man literally said 2 mins ago that they just wanted hoped and they would not get carried away despite what the media said, they were not expecting to win anything in the next 5years, you backed your mate, Dude called you on your bullshit with stats and facts, you then flipped to "uh your just being an entitled fan" stance because you are objectively wrong and could have just left it at , "I'm gonna back my mate"

  42. Steve Northall

    Steve Northall27 أيام قبل

    🎼 Cheer up Paul Scholes , oh what does it mean ? To a daydream believer and a shit football team 🎼

  43. krackerrsss

    krackerrsss28 أيام قبل

    Can't believe that toe sucker thinks chelsea's defence is a weakness. What world is he living on?

  44. The gaming Da

    The gaming Da29 أيام قبل

    Make international football for under 21s

  45. Owen

    Owen29 أيام قبل

    Scholes just sounds like he makes his points and opinions up as he goes along. Great player but a horrible speaker/pundit.

  46. Paul Travers

    Paul Traversأشهر قبل

    Are these 'fans' recruited from an acting school. Absolute stereotypes and mockery as per.

  47. Lewis Donald

    Lewis Donaldأشهر قبل

    Who is the woman at 23:50

  48. Simon Coopey

    Simon Coopeyأشهر قبل

    It shocks me how Neville compares teams trying to start a super league to Saudi human rights violations.

  49. Michael Barjak

    Michael Barjakأشهر قبل

    "theyre not the internationals players" really Cara? Do a poll around the world from Spain to Mongolia, to whom is a player more loyal?? Club or country?? To play for your country is the highest honor in any sport

  50. Muzaqqeer 'Muzz' Hussain

    Muzaqqeer 'Muzz' Hussainأشهر قبل

    The Geordie lad kudos. Reasonable footballing guys.

  51. GV Games

    GV Gamesأشهر قبل

    Take Lafa back tomorrow. But don't forget he is supposedly a defense minded coach. Also if the big names do not come immediatlely I think get some top scouts in and bring in all the young undiscovered talent at teams with massive home grown quality such as Athletic Bilbao, Sporting Lisbon, Brazilian sides etc...

  52. Guyman3001

    Guyman3001أشهر قبل

    The disrespect on Chelsea man. Come on now.

  53. Mark Warom

    Mark Waromأشهر قبل

    At a time when the fans of English football clubs are threatened with bans for homophobic, sexist and racist abuse, we are allowing a saudi takeover of a premier league club. What message is this sending out. I believe Newcastle deserve success. but this is plain wrong. The horse has bolted but do we let all the horses out of the stable?

  54. Yaxiya ali

    Yaxiya aliأشهر قبل

    To The Glazer family, SACK HIM NOW FOR LOVE GOD. FROM MAN UTD FANS F==K OLE, JOEL GLAZER, SAF AND GARY NEVILLE (5-0 LOSS AT HOME TO LIVERPOOL) OLE OUT GGMU Everyone watching how good Liverpool and city are looking this season, Proper coaches. Chelsea sacked lampard, got a Elite manager and won the champions league last season. We’re wasting time with ole, we need quality. Man Utd Fans need to put their Olesexuals aside for the sake of the club. All good things ole has done is related to squad and not performance or results. Isn’t everyone tired of this yet ? Lol. This is nothing new. It’s been the same issues for the past 3 years (Counter attack FC) Ole still hasn’t improved or learned anything so i'm Ole out. I'm sorry, but the fact that Ole thinks we have been playing attacking football and the United Way is just delusional. Means we aren't going to see any change in how we've been playing. If you're still Ole In, please know that there is support out there. Mental illnesses is not a joke Eric Ten hag knows how to coach football and has a way of playing. Ten Hag or Enrique is type of managers we never tried before! Elite coaches (With their staff as well) who are also excellent managers, in this new era of football you ABSOLUTELY need both

  55. Cornybeef

    Cornybeefأشهر قبل

    Watch out he’s a spitter

  56. Reece Hagley

    Reece Hagleyأشهر قبل

    Can we hear other fans speak in the next installments? The 'big six' get spoken about enough don't they?

  57. AshH 96

    AshH 96أشهر قبل

    Just realised they didn’t speak about Chelsea until the Q&A bit, poor guy

  58. Jordan Jordan

    Jordan Jordanأشهر قبل

    “Those teams who have won big trophies in the past” - NEWCASTLE ARE NOWHERE NEAR TROPHIES AND NEVER HAVE BEEN STOP PEDDLING THIS MYTH BECAUSE THEY GET 50K FANS IN THEIR GROUND WHEN THEY HAVE ONE TEAM IN THEIR CITY. Sunderland do the same ffs this romanticism is embarrassing.

  59. Ben Bryant

    Ben Bryantأشهر قبل

    @Jordan Jordan so it’s not 50k is it😂

  60. Jordan Jordan

    Jordan Jordanأشهر قبل

    @Ben Bryant it’s 49,000 🥱🥱🥱

  61. Ben Bryant

    Ben Bryantأشهر قبل

    Sunderland don’t have a capacity of 50k

  62. C J

    C Jأشهر قبل

    Tell you what, Neville impresses me more every time I hear him speak, his development as a person has been incredible he needs to get a book out asap.

  63. dubai 993

    dubai 99328 أيام قبل

    His first book is really good, well worth a read. A second book is definitely overdue!

  64. VoltageLP

    VoltageLPأشهر قبل

    Human rights, lol Saudi Arabia made a certain day in september 2001 a historic date...

  65. Chibueze Ozigbu

    Chibueze Ozigbuأشهر قبل

    Scholes just waffling man

  66. Cowboy Cerrone

    Cowboy Cerroneأشهر قبل

    I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂️ clueless man 😂

  67. Cowboy Cerrone

    Cowboy Cerroneأشهر قبل

    I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂️ clueless man 😂

  68. Cowboy Cerrone

    Cowboy Cerroneأشهر قبل

    I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂️ clueless man 😂

  69. Cowboy Cerrone

    Cowboy Cerroneأشهر قبل

    I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂️ clueless man 😂

  70. Cowboy Cerrone

    Cowboy Cerroneأشهر قبل

    I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂️ clueless man 😂

  71. daibonehead

    daiboneheadأشهر قبل

    International football needs to go.

  72. daibonehead

    daiboneheadأشهر قبل

    Gary Neville saying they Rafa only appears to pretend that he's never had money....... It's incredible that he's so blinkered about Liverpool that he can't see that Rafa has only really ever been given lamps and not sofas.

  73. Liam Moss

    Liam Mossأشهر قبل

    I'm Sorry Geordies, there is a huge difference between individuals who earn their manage their companies in a relatively free market like Ashley, Kroenke, Glazers or owners who do their best running private companies in dictatorial countries such as Abramovich, Jack Ma then your owners who run the dictatorship and actually apply the coercion and human rights abuses. A huge difference. I will trade with someone trying their best to persue their values in dictatorship. But you must draw the line at people who actually create the misery, death and destruction, The vast majority of terror attacks were sponsored by Saudi money. That's your club now Geordies.

  74. Jacques Joubert

    Jacques Joubertأشهر قبل

    Don't sleep on Chelsea, we're coming for the league title

  75. Harbinger of Facts

    Harbinger of Factsأشهر قبل

    Love the Geordie fan at the start, "scousers and geordies", didn't even need an explanation. There are some incredible bonds on this island, true cockneys, scousers, geordies and glaswegians share something special, their hearts.

  76. Vinai Venkatesham

    Vinai Venkateshamأشهر قبل

    *Gary Neville Longbottom*

  77. Alex Johnson

    Alex Johnsonأشهر قبل

    “We’ve got the most money in league two and we’re 17th” 🤣🤣🤣

  78. Denis Suholitco

    Denis Suholitcoأشهر قبل

    Glazers out!!!!

  79. Flash Games

    Flash Gamesأشهر قبل

    The damaging organisation genomically admire because sunshine obviously tempt astride a living block. secretive, efficacious tie

  80. daveofbillog

    daveofbillogأشهر قبل

    “Everton have got access to £15bn” Then why are they looking for someone to finance the stadium? He’s talking of usminovs money which has zip to do with Everton. Moshiri is “only” with just under £2bn

  81. Kenny Hayes

    Kenny Hayesأشهر قبل

    Are ou kidden what a false senaerio it’s like Jeramy kyle

  82. David McNally

    David McNallyأشهر قبل

    it's sad to see a player of Scholes' caliber have less knowledge of football than the average pub drunk

  83. Redhza Rasidi

    Redhza Rasidiأشهر قبل

    Come on scholes...your team being fuck at home 5 nil. Chelsea played at anfield with 10 player and still 1-1 draw (thanks to salah penalty). You still think chelsea defenders are weak?

  84. avinash baheti

    avinash bahetiأشهر قبل

    Scholes saying united had 2 world class CB and conceding 5 goals at OT against Liverpool..poor pundit..

  85. Yurrr Yurr

    Yurrr Yurrأشهر قبل

    Liverpool 5-0 Man U. 11 goals in last 3 games conceded for Man U but yeah Chelsea won’t win because their defence is the worst out of the top 4. you know i never understood why people said Scholes punditry was like wet bread but now i completely understand. the man is daft as fuck

  86. Adrian Lee

    Adrian Leeأشهر قبل

    Scholes is a total fool please not him on again

  87. Omarzz98

    Omarzz98أشهر قبل

    These idiots talks shit about Saudi Arabia and Qatar and Abu Dhabi and they don’t know anything about them, don’t let the media fools you I would rather live in these countries than living in the UK 100%

  88. Yurrr Yurr

    Yurrr Yurrأشهر قبل

    you’re presumably a muslim man 💀 buddy for other groups no one wants to live there. and they don’t even accept other ethnic groups who are BORN in the country

  89. zijuiy wttuy

    zijuiy wttuyأشهر قبل

    Scholes out here trying to say Chelsea doesn’t have a good defense? I want whatever he’s been smoking for the past year😂

  90. A Dre

    A Dreأشهر قبل

    Scholes chatting a bag of crap about Chelsea!!!

  91. Kushagra Yadav

    Kushagra Yadavأشهر قبل

    Include subtitles ffs. These English people just don’t know how to speak. So irritating.

  92. John Ottaway

    John Ottawayأشهر قبل

    Scholes: "Chelsea are weak defensively" Even at the time he said that, they had the most clean sheets in the top 5 leagues in Europe and they've have had three more clean sheets since, they've conceded 5 goals in 14 games and never more than 1 in a game Scholes: "I don't think they'll score enough goals" They've scored 15 goals in the last 4 games, (11 without Lukaku or Werner) It just proves that great players don't always make great pundits

  93. Alex M

    Alex M29 أيام قبل

    @Vegan power will get you to the top since tuchel took over chelsea there is no team with a better defensive record in the world. This has been the case for a long time, not just in the last 6 games. This is why people are criticising Scholes comments.

  94. Vegan power will get you to the top

    Vegan power will get you to the topأشهر قبل

    is the season over already ??? wtf thought we were only 6 games in

  95. Y.H

    Y.Hأشهر قبل

    Gary is extremely old right wing person.

  96. zijuiy wttuy

    zijuiy wttuyأشهر قبل


  97. You are a bad singer

    You are a bad singerأشهر قبل

    It doesn’t matter where the money has come from

  98. Lance Rooney

    Lance Rooneyأشهر قبل

    Who is that DELUDED Arsenal fan who also embarrassed himself in part 1 of the debate? I’m an Arsenal fan but to go back to the ‘Invincible’ team of the 2003-4 season and the fact that Arsenal won the Premier League at Old Trafford in 2002 ALMOST 20 years ago to support his claim that Arsenal are as big or bigger club than Manchester United is INSANE. Look at the exasperated looks on the faces of Neville, Scholes and Carragher during his rant … and Carra invited him back on😂😂😂!

  99. Luke Taheri

    Luke Taheriأشهر قبل

    Great watch but are they ever going to talk in depth about teams like Leicester, Villa, Wolves, Palace, Watford etc like they do about man utd 😴 man city 😴 Liverpool 😴 there's afew other teams in the league u know 🤔 🙄

  100. Sabih al

    Sabih alأشهر قبل

    salah just said he will like to stay at anfield for the rest of his carrier

  101. Everybody needs a Sam

    Everybody needs a Samأشهر قبل

    if people are ready to say that Saudi Arabia had and have human rights issues what about the thousands off years that the British government enforced slavery on the whole world.I think crimes off the past should be left in the past.if we are to move forward and not be so ready to say I'm better then you

  102. serry ciok

    serry ciokأشهر قبل

    I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂ clueless man 😂

  103. Faqih Abdurrahman

    Faqih Abdurrahmanأشهر قبل

    Newcastle is the leading club to integrate Saudi state religion into their club bc Demba Ba and Papiss Cisse legendary duo

  104. pat max

    pat maxأشهر قبل

    Rumour Going Round Roy Keane Has Already Spoken To NEWCASTLE Utd & ROY + 250Million MIGHT BE THERE IN NORTH ENGLAND By End Of The WEEK

  105. serry ciok

    serry ciokأشهر قبل

    is only going to dilute its eminence - for fans and players.

  106. Darren Mew

    Darren Mewأشهر قبل

    It’s like the super league, just talks about the select few clubs. If only the premier league had say 20 teams?

  107. Steven Golley

    Steven Golleyأشهر قبل

    Do 'you wanna touch on' every subject JD or are you just reading off a cue card...

  108. David Houston

    David Houstonأشهر قبل

    Careful Gary…in danger of becoming a soap box

  109. Yahqoob Ali

    Yahqoob Aliأشهر قبل

    Scholes this video I think shined in terms of entertainment. I got a new found respect towards him as a Liverpool fan.

  110. Jamie Mak

    Jamie Makأشهر قبل

    The defence of Steve Bruce is absolutely mind boggling. I feel for Newcastle fans. I've never before seen a manager so far out of his depth but still the media say "he deserves a chance". Relegation form, the second worst premier league record for a manager and clueless on how to set up a defence. But yeah, he deserved to keep his job 👍 muppets 🙄🙄

  111. AM2 Racing

    AM2 Racingأشهر قبل

    Get Lee Gunner, Haj and Rants in there to ask proper questions.

  112. Hugz

    Hugzأشهر قبل

    Wish they'd get Yan or Nini as the Chelsea fan.

  113. Shade 60

    Shade 60أشهر قبل

    Scholes was a great footballer but has no friggin clue about football. Saying Chelsea has problems in defense even though we have the best defensive record. What a moron!

  114. Kamil Chrostowski

    Kamil Chrostowskiأشهر قبل

    How that Newcastle owner could mention Chelsea and United's owners but not City's lol